Skip to main content
On a slow or spotty connection?
Budget

Taylor 5924 Refrigerator/Freezer Dial Thermometer

A battery-free dial thermometer that shows whether your fridge is at or below 40°F and your freezer at or below 0°F, the FDA's safe lines. Owners report some units a few degrees off, so check yours.

Our score: 4 out of 5

Does the job in an outage
4
Holds up
3
Easy to use under stress
4.5
Value for what it does
4.5
How we score

Who this is for

Every household with a fridge and freezer, as a baseline check during and after an outage.

Skip if

Anyone needing to know how long the fridge was too warm without opening the door; it has no memory.

Taylor 5924 Refrigerator/Freezer Dial Thermometer

Evaluated for household use · Affiliate links disclosed

A reliable option for most households

Why we chose it

It's the simple answer to "is the food still safe?": no batteries, NSF certified per Taylor, and a dial marked with safe zones.

Buy From

Amazon

Also available at

Affiliate links · We earn a small commission at no cost to you. How this works
We evaluate every pick for real-world reliability.

Why this matters

Why this matters in an emergency

When the power's out, the question about the food in the fridge is a number, not a feeling. The FDA says to keep the fridge at or below 40°F and the freezer at or below 0°F, and to keep a thermometer in each so you can tell whether the food is safe. "It still feels cold" is a guess. A thermometer turns it into an answer.

That answer matters most when the power comes back. The FDA says an unopened fridge keeps food cold for about 4 hours, and a full freezer for about 48. If the freezer thermometer reads 40°F or below when power returns, the FDA says the food is safe and can be refrozen. You can't rely on how food looks or smells, per the FDA. A thermometer you already own is how you know.

How We Evaluated

How we evaluated this

We researched the Taylor 5924 from Taylor's own product page and package card, the Amazon listing (sold by Amazon), and the most recent critical owner reviews, which tell us how accurate it is in real kitchens. The food-safety numbers come from the FDA, USDA and Ready.gov. We don't have hands-on time with it yet, so every figure is credited to its source.

Our pick: Taylor 5924 Refrigerator/Freezer Dial Thermometer

The verdict

The Taylor 5924 is a plain dial thermometer for your fridge and freezer. It needs no batteries, so it works through any outage, and the 3-inch dial is marked with safe zones. It answers the question that matters when the power comes back. The FDA says freezer food is safe to refreeze if the freezer thermometer reads 40°F or below. Without a thermometer, you're guessing. The catch is accuracy. Owners often report units reading a few degrees off, and Taylor doesn't publish an accuracy figure. Check yours against a second thermometer before you rely on it.

Strengths
  • No batteries: works through any outage
  • 3-inch dial with safe-zone markings
  • Covers fridge and freezer: -20 to 80°F
  • NSF certified, per Taylor
Limitations
  • Units can read a few degrees off
  • No memory of the warmest reading
  • You open the door to read it

What it does well

It's simple. It's a mechanical dial, so there's nothing to charge or replace. It hangs from a shelf or stands on its own, and Taylor lists it as NSF certified.

It covers both compartments. The Amazon listing gives its range as -20 to 80°F. Taylor's package card marks the safe zone at 32 to 40°F for the fridge and -20 to 0°F for the freezer.

What to know before you buy

  • Units can read a few degrees off. Taylor states no accuracy figure, and owners report readings 2 to 10 degrees off their other thermometers.
  • No memory. It shows the temperature now, not the warmest it got while the power was out, and you open the door to read it.
  • Hand wash only. Taylor says not to put it in water or the dishwasher.

This, or a digital thermometer with memory?

A digital fridge thermometer with min/max memory can show the warmest temperature reached during an outage, often without opening the door. It needs batteries. The Taylor shows you the temperature now and never runs down. If you're home during outages, one Taylor in the fridge and one in the freezer is enough. If you're often away, a min/max thermometer tells you what you missed.

How long will the food stay safe?

The planning numbers, from the FDA:

  • Keep it cold: the fridge at or below 40°F, the freezer at or below 0°F.
  • Door closed: an unopened fridge keeps food cold about 4 hours. A full freezer holds about 48 hours, a half-full one about 24.
  • Throw out: refrigerated perishables that sat above 40°F for 4 hours or more. Ready.gov is stricter: 40°F or higher for 2 hours or more. When in doubt, throw it out.
  • Refreeze: freezer food is safe to refreeze if the freezer thermometer reads 40°F or below.

You can't rely on how food looks or smells, the FDA says. That's why the thermometer matters.

What owners report

In recent critical Amazon reviews, nearly every complaint is accuracy. Owners report units reading 2 to 10 degrees off their other thermometers, and two owners found a pair reading 2 to 3 degrees apart side by side. One said theirs read fine for five months and then drifted. Others praise the large, easy-to-read dial.

Other options to consider

  • A digital fridge thermometer with min/max memory

    Shows the warmest temperature reached while you were away, and some also record how long it stayed too warm, without opening the door. More to set up, and it needs batteries.

Longevity

How long will this actually last

There's nothing to charge and nothing to wear out but the dial. Taylor includes a limited warranty.

Check it once a year. USDA checks food thermometers in a glass of well-stirred ice water, which should read 32°F, and you can do the same here. If it reads off, note the difference and allow for it.

Questions people actually ask

Where should I put it?
Keep one in the fridge and one in the freezer, as the FDA advises. USDA suggests the middle of the fridge, and between frozen packages in the freezer. Put it where you can see it as soon as you open the door.
How do I know if my food is still safe after an outage?
The FDA says to throw out refrigerated perishables like meat, milk, eggs and leftovers that were above 40°F for 4 hours or more. Ready.gov is stricter: 40°F or higher for 2 hours or more. When in doubt, throw it out.
Can I refreeze food from the freezer?
The FDA says yes, if the freezer thermometer reads 40°F or below when the power comes back. Without a thermometer, check each package for ice crystals.
How accurate is it?
Taylor doesn't state a figure, and owners report units a few degrees off. Check yours against a second thermometer, or in a glass of ice water, which should read about 32°F.

Technical Specifications

TypeMechanical dial; no batteries
Dial3 in, with safe-zone markings (Taylor)
Range-20 to 80°F (Amazon listing)
Safe ZonesFridge 32–40°F; freezer -20–0°F (Taylor package card)
MountingHangs or stands (Taylor)
CertificationNSF certified (Taylor)
CaseStainless steel (Amazon listing)
AccuracyNot stated by Taylor
CareHand wash only; don't immerse in water or put in the dishwasher (Taylor)
WarrantyLimited warranty (Taylor)

Sources we consulted

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. How this works

Taylor 5924 Refrigerator/Freezer Dial Thermometer

Evaluated for household use · Affiliate links disclosed

A reliable option for most households

Why we chose it

It's the simple answer to "is the food still safe?": no batteries, NSF certified per Taylor, and a dial marked with safe zones.

Buy From

Amazon

Also available at

Affiliate links · We earn a small commission at no cost to you. How this works
We evaluate every pick for real-world reliability.